When you run a nonprofit business, your livelihood often depends on donors and volunteers to keep the doors open. And while your message is usually different from those of for-profit businesses, the methods of getting that message out are exactly the same — and direct mail is a staple of those methods.
For-profit businesses need to stay in front of their customers, and nonprofits need to stay in front of their donors — simple as that. But while it may be simple in principle, it might feel like a logistical nightmare in practice.
Too much direct mail, and you’ll be wasting your budget on a diminishing return…possibly even annoying your prospects. Too little, and you’ll fail to encourage your donor base or even stick around in their memory. So how do you find that perfect sweet spot?
That’s what we’re here to explore. At Integra, we’ve worked on hundreds of direct mail campaigns over our nearly two decades in business. Many of those campaigns and ongoing, scheduled mailings have been with nonprofits across innumerable sectors, and we’ve always managed to find the sweet spot. We’d like to help you do the same, so in this article, we’ll cover:
- Recommended frequency and mailer type for nonprofit direct mail newsletters
- Recommended frequency and mailer type for nonprofit direct mail appeal letters
- Recommended frequency and mailer type for nonprofit direct mail volunteer requests
- Recommended frequency and mailer type for nonprofit event invitations and reminders
The strategic use of direct mail can significantly enhance your nonprofit's efforts, provided the frequency and types of mailers are well-suited to your organization's goals. So let's make sure you have great alignment so you can meet and exceed all expectations with your next campaign!
1. Nonprofit Direct Mail Newsletters: Sustaining Engagement
Frequency: Twice per year or quarterly
Mailer Type: Enveloped letters, booklets or self-mailers
Why This Choice?
Newsletters serve as the backbone of regular communication with your supporter base. By opting for a biannual or quarterly frequency, nonprofits can compile meaningful content that resonates with readers, avoiding the superficiality that might come from more frequent, less substantial updates.
Standard newsletters allow for a mix of content types, including updates, stories and upcoming events, which can keep the audience engaged without them feeling overwhelmed.
2. Nonprofit Direct Mail Appeal Letters: Driving Donations
Frequency: Twice per year or quarterly
Mailer Type: Enveloped letters or self-mailers
Why This Choice?
Appeal letters are more focused and targeted than newsletters. They aim to pull at the heartstrings and open wallets, requiring a direct and personal touch. Sending these letters biannually or quarterly aligns with strategic fundraising times, such as end-of-year giving, mid-year campaigns and holiday spirit.
Personalized appeal letters can address recipients by name, reflect their previous contributions and carefully detail what new funds will achieve, making each letter feel thoughtful and impactful. That said, if you go this route, you'll want to consider envelopes for the number of benefits they offer.
3. Nonprofit Direct Mail Volunteer Requests: Activating Supporters
Frequency: As needed
Mailer Type: Postcards or special bulletins
Why This Choice?
When a specific need for volunteers arises, timing and attention-grabbing design are key. Postcards and special bulletins are perfect for these occasions due to their visual appeal and succinct message delivery. They can also be quickly produced and distributed, which is ideal for rallying immediate support. The concise format ensures the message is clear and actionable, crucial for time-sensitive requests like event support and project participation.
4. Nonprofit Direct Mail Event Invitations and Reminders: Maximizing Attendance
Frequency: Prior to events
Mailer Type: Invitational postcards, digital follow-up
Why This Choice?
For events, the goal is to maximize awareness and attendance with timely and attractive reminders. Invitational postcards sent well in advance, followed by a reminder closer to the event date, are effective in catching attention. Their visual appeal makes them stand out in a mailbox, and their straightforward format communicates essential event details succinctly, which is crucial for busy donors who may skim their mail.
With event invitations, you may want to try out a platform that pairs direct mail with digital engagement on social media, such as Integra's SynergyMail platform. Doing so will catch more people where they're at and remind them of an event they may have otherwise forgotten.
Use Direct Mail for Nonprofits to Your Advantage With Well-Timed Mailings
Choosing the right type and frequency of mailers for your nonprofit's direct mail campaigns is crucial to maintaining donor engagement and ensuring your messages are both seen and acted upon. Whether you're looking to boost donations, recruit volunteers or invite guests to a special event, understanding the strategic use of different mailer types can significantly enhance your outreach efforts.
If you think you might want to change it up a bit with your own direct mail campaigns, take a look at your direct mail mailer options in our comprehensive article on the topic. You may choose to go a different route than what we've suggested in terms of your materials. That's perfectly fine, but we strongly recommend sticking to the goal-based timelines outlined here no matter what style of mailers you're sending.
At Integra Graphics Synergy, we specialize in creating tailored direct mail strategies that resonate with audiences and amplify each nonprofit's mission. If you're ready for a partner with that kind of commitment, reach out below to get your project started.
Topics:
